Beach Plum: How Can We Help You?

August 3, 2020
Dear Fishers Islanders,

It’s hard to believe we are halfway through this summer.  It continues to be a different one, but we are grateful to all our community who are following the IHP and NYS rules and protocols.  We look forward to seeing some new faces this month – just a reminder, you MUST wear a mask, shoppers are limited, no unaccompanied children and if you just arrived from a “hot” state, please follow your quarantine mandates.

Tuesday – Saturday – 10:00 – 1:00 & 3:00 – 5:00
Sunday – Monday – 10:00 – 1:00.  
Please respect our closed times as they allow us to clean and restock safely.

Curb-side pick-up will continue – if you are more comfortable shopping over the phone/email and picking up, we are happy to help.  Call us – 631-788-7731.  And for those not on island this summer – we are happy to help shop remotely – and our website is always open –

The store is filled with tons of goodies – lots of great summer clothes and gifts, new Tervis designs and our custom FI masks & buffs are back in stock.  And as always, we are happy to help with special orders from Matouk, Dash & Albert, Pine Cone Hill, John Robshaw and Get Lit.  Let us know what you are looking for!

Hope to see you all soon –
Heather & Jamie

Little Plum News

We have ONE Trunk Show scheduled for August in the Little Plum.  Hosting off island vendors is obviously complicated this summer and this show only works because it will be staffed by two on-island people who have been following the IHP protocols.

Click to see details

at the Little Plum this
Wednesday – Friday, August 5 – 7 from
9:00 – 5:00.


  • You MUST wear a mask. There is hand sanitizer as you enter and checkout.
  • Limit of 4 shoppers.
  • Please social distance while shopping and waiting to come in.
  • Please NO unaccompanied children.
  • Our changing room/bathroom is currently closed to the public.  We will be allowing customers to bring up to 4 items home overnight to try on.
  • No gift-wrapping.
  • Credit card payment is preferred.
  • Curb-side service is still available.
April 27, 2020
Dear Fishers Islanders,

A month has passed since our last email and not much has changed.  We are still hunkered down and abiding by the protocols in place to keep our families and our island community safe.

As we all navigate our new normals, we want to offer you our personal shopping services.  We have been busy this past month and are well stocked with the perfect Mothers Day & Graduation gifts (and cards), tons of puzzles and great new kids activities.  Our summer clothing is starting to arrive and as always, we have the perfect gift for everyone in your family.  Jamie and I are happy to put together ideas and can text, email or FaceTime you with our suggestions.  To start that process, please email me – – and one of us will get back to you.

If you are looking for a FI themed gifts, your best bet is still – Tons of Fishers items available and we have added some new items.

Like every small business, we thank you all for your continued support.  We look forward to seeing you all in person when it is safe for us to do so.

Stay safe and healthy –
Heather & Jamie

New Harding Lane Colors…
Four new colors of our favorite Harding Lane Fishers Island Baseball Caps – $35
Shown: Camo and Orange.  Not shown: Bright Pink, Slate Blue and Seafoam Green AND new kids colors available too!
Check out our newest Chandler 4 Corners
Hooked Rug!
The patriotic colors of this wool hooked rug are a great addition to any house.  Other designs still available – New London Ledge and a redo of our original green island version. $135.
Heather F. Burnham
The Beach Plum
Phone: 631.788.7731
March 26, 2020
Dear Fishers Islanders,
We had hoped to be sending this blast out with information about our Easter Weekend opening and with a glimpse of the new lines we have coming this summer, but the last few weeks have changed all that. Like the rest of the world, we are hunkered down and heeding the directives that are in place to keep us all safe.  We are still preparing (working separately and mostly remotely) to open when we are told its okay to – and we do have some fun new stuff en-route. Jamie and I look forward to sharing that all with you soon!In the meantime, please consider making a purchase through our website – Tons of Fishers items available!  Our season will be shorter than normal and like every small business out there, we appreciate your support as we navigate this time together.  As a further incentive, we are offering 20% off your entire online purchase through Easter – see below!We will be shipping through USPS and for anyone on island, we can arrange for a curbside pick up or delivery.  Please no stopping by the store.

Stay safe and healthy –
Heather & Jamie

Check Also

Thanksgiving Week @ The Beach Plum

Hours, protocals, and sale info!